Scoring enquiry quality: which leads deserve a call first

Not every enquiry deserves the same effort. A simple score tells you who to call first.

The short answer. Score each enquiry on a few things you can see, such as job type, timing, location, budget and source, give each a few points and call the highest scores first. Then feed the score or the outcome back to your ads so they learn to find more of the good ones.

Why score

When enquiries arrive, time is limited. A score points you at the ones most likely to become work, and shows which sources send the best leads.

A simple scheme (illustrative)

SignalPoints
In your service area+2
Wants the job within a month+2
Budget in your range+2
Called rather than filled in a form+1
Outside your area or no timing0 or negative

Adjust the signals to your business. Keep it simple enough to use.

Act on it

  • Call high scores first, and fast.
  • Send low scores a helpful automatic reply.
  • Review the score against real outcomes monthly.

Feed it back to your ads

Report qualified or booked leads back to Google and Meta so they optimise for quality, not volume. See how to improve lead quality.

A worked example (illustrative)

A conservatory firm gives 2 points each for being in the area, wanting the job within three months and a budget in range, and 1 point for a phone call. Leads with 5 or more points get a call within 10 minutes. Leads with 0 to 2 get an automatic helpful email. After a month it sees that 70 percent of booked jobs came from leads scoring 5 or more. Illustrative.

Common mistakes

  • Too many signals to maintain.
  • Never checking the score against outcomes.
  • Ignoring low scores entirely.
  • Not feeding outcomes back to the ads.

Common questions

Do I need software for lead scoring?

No. A simple points system in a spreadsheet works. A CRM can automate it.

How many signals should I use?

Three to five. More than that is hard to maintain.

Can scoring replace judgement?

No. It is a first filter. A person still decides who to call and what to say.

Keep reading

Edward EatonEdward EatonMarketing and ads specialist

Want help putting this into practice?

Send a few details about your business and your current ads. You will get an honest view of what to fix first.

Or email edward@edwardeatonmarketing.com or call 07817 574416. More about Edward