Your own ads or paid lead sites like Checkatrade and MyBuilder?
Paid lead sites rent you someone else's audience. Your own ads build one you control. Both have a place.
The short answer. Paid lead and directory sites can bring leads quickly but you often pay per lead or per membership, share leads with competitors and own none of the audience. Your own Google and Meta ads cost more to set up but give you control, your own data and leads that go only to you. Many firms use both while building their own channel.
Paid lead and directory sites
Sites such as Checkatrade and MyBuilder connect homeowners with tradespeople. Terms vary, with some charging per lead or a membership. Check each site's current pricing and rules.
| Paid lead sites | Your own ads | |
|---|---|---|
| Speed | Quick to start | Needs setup and testing |
| Control | Limited. Their rules and their listing. | Full. Your message, area and budget. |
| Competition | Leads are often shared with other firms | Leads go to you |
| Data and audience | Belong to the platform | Belong to you |
| Cost pattern | Per lead or membership | Ad spend plus management |
How to combine them
- Use a lead site if it gives you work at a profitable cost.
- Start your own Google ads for people searching your service and area.
- Add Meta to show finished work and retarget.
- Compare cost per booked job across all sources.
Why build your own channel
Your own ads give you your own data, your reviews and your reputation, and you are not dependent on another platform changing its terms. See Google or Meta for home improvement.
A worked example (illustrative)
A roofer pays a lead site £35 per lead and wins 1 in 8 shared leads, so a job costs £280. His own Google ads bring leads at £28 and he wins 1 in 4 because they are exclusive, so a job costs £112. He keeps the lead site for quiet periods and puts more into his own ads. Illustrative sums, to show the method.
Common mistakes
- Comparing price per lead only.
- Ignoring that leads are shared.
- Not tracking by source.
- Depending on one platform.
Common questions
Are lead sites worth it?
They can be, if leads convert to booked jobs at a profitable cost. Track cost per booked job for each source.
Can I use lead sites and my own ads together?
Yes. Many firms do while they build their own channel.
Which is cheaper?
It depends on the trade and area. Compare cost per booked job, not cost per lead.