What discounting really costs: the extra volume you need to win back

Discounts feel harmless. They are not. You lose profit on every unit and need to sell more to make it back.

The short answer. The extra volume you need to keep the same total gross profit is the discount divided by the gross margin minus the discount. With a 40 per cent margin, a 10 per cent discount means selling 33.3 per cent more to stand still. At a 20 per cent margin, the same discount means doubling your sales.

From the Marketing Strategy course by Edward Eaton. See what is inside.

The formula

Required volume increase = discount / (gross margin minus discount). With a margin of 40% and a discount of 10%, that is 10 / (40 - 10) = 33.3%.

Why it works

Before: price £100, cost £60, profit £40 a unit. After a 10% discount: price £90, profit £30 a unit. To earn the same total you need 40 / 30 = 1.333 times the units, which is 33.3% more.

The table

Gross margin5% discount10% discount15% discount
20%33.3%100.0%300.0%
30%20.0%50.0%100.0%
40%14.3%33.3%60.0%
50%11.1%25.0%42.9%

Each cell is the discount divided by the margin minus the discount. For a 30% margin and a 15% discount: 15 / (30 - 15) = 100%.

How to read it

  • The lower your margin, the more dangerous a discount is.
  • A small discount can still need a big jump in sales.
  • If you cannot realistically win that extra volume, the discount loses you money.

Alternatives to discounting

  • Add something of value instead of cutting the price.
  • Offer good, better and best packages.
  • Use a guarantee to reduce risk.
  • Keep discounts for a clear reason and a time limit that is real.

Pricing also sends a message about quality. See value based pricing for how to set the price in the first place.

Common questions

Why does a small discount need so much extra volume?

Because your margin is a small slice of the price. A discount takes a big share of that slice, so you must sell many more units to earn the same profit.

Do discounts ever make sense?

Sometimes, for example to fill spare capacity or reward a clear commitment. Work out the extra volume you need first.

Does the table include VAT?

Use prices and costs excluding VAT if you are VAT registered, so the margins reflect what you keep.

Keep reading

From the course

Marketing Strategy

Marketing Strategy is a 117 page course with an Excel toolkit. It takes you from diagnosis to a written strategy, a budget and a 90 day plan, with worked examples and templates.

Edward EatonEdward EatonMarketing and ads specialist

Want help putting this into practice?

Send a few details about your business and what you want to achieve. You will get an honest view of what to do first.

Or email edward@edwardeatonmarketing.com or call 07817 574416. More about Edward