Five tests for a real competitive advantage

A strength is something you are good at. An advantage is a reason customers choose you that competitors cannot easily match.

The short answer. A competitive advantage is a reason customers choose you over the alternatives, that you can keep delivering, and that competitors cannot easily match. Test any candidate against five questions: is it noticed, valued, believed, hard to copy and sustainable? Friendly staff and high quality usually fail, while a dated guarantee or a long track record can pass.

From the Marketing Strategy course by Edward Eaton. See what is inside.

The five tests

#TestQuestion
1NoticedDo customers see it before they buy?
2ValuedDo they care enough to pay more, choose you or wait for you?
3BelievedCan you prove it, or is it just a claim?
4Hard to copyWould it take a competitor years or real cost to match it?
5SustainableCan you keep delivering it as you grow, without heroics?

A worked example (illustrative): a bathroom firm

CandidateNoticedValuedBelievedHard to copySustainablePasses
Friendly staffYesYesNoNoYes3 of 5
Fixed price in writingYesYesYesNoYes4 of 5
Dated fitting guarantee with a payment if we miss itYesYesYesYesYes5 of 5
12 years and 300 reviewsYesYesYesYesYes5 of 5
"High quality"NoYesNoNoYes2 of 5

Reading it: the fixed price is worth doing but copyable. The dated guarantee and the track record pass every test, so they become the pillars of the advantage. "High quality" and "friendly" are expected and prove nothing, so assume them and do not use them as headlines.

Three routes to advantage

Michael Porter described cost leadership, differentiation and focus. Small firms rarely win on cost, because bigger firms usually have scale. Many win by being different in a way customers value, or by focusing on a narrow group and serving it better than generalists.

Avoid being stuck in the middle

Trying to be cheapest, best and a specialist at once leaves you with no clear advantage. Choose one to three advantages and build your pages, ads and sales process around them. Then work out your positioning.

Common questions

What is the difference between a strength and an advantage?

A strength is something you do well. An advantage is something customers notice, value and believe, that competitors find hard to copy and that you can keep delivering.

Can a small business have a competitive advantage?

Yes. A local reputation, a specialism, a guarantee or a better way of working can all pass the tests.

Is low price an advantage?

Rarely for a small firm. Larger competitors usually have more scale, so differentiation or focus is often a safer route.

Keep reading

From the course

Marketing Strategy

Marketing Strategy is a 117 page course with an Excel toolkit. It takes you from diagnosis to a written strategy, a budget and a 90 day plan, with worked examples and templates.

Edward EatonEdward EatonMarketing and ads specialist

Want help putting this into practice?

Send a few details about your business and what you want to achieve. You will get an honest view of what to do first.

Or email edward@edwardeatonmarketing.com or call 07817 574416. More about Edward