Five signs your marketing strategy is really a wish list
If nothing is ruled out, you probably do not have a strategy yet.
The short answer. Five signs of bad strategy: fluff in place of meaning, failure to face the challenge, goals mistaken for strategy, a long list of priorities that do not fit together, and no trade offs. A real strategy makes some customers, channels and offers off limits.
From the Marketing Strategy course by Edward Eaton. See what is inside.
The five signs
- Fluff. Grand words with no meaning, such as "world class customer centric solutions".
- Failure to face the challenge. There is no diagnosis, so no way to tell whether the actions fit.
- Goals mistaken for strategy. "Increase sales by 30 per cent" with no explanation of how.
- Bad objectives. A long list of priorities that do not fit together or tackle the real obstacle.
- No trade offs. Nothing is ruled out.
Strategy against a wish list
| A strategy says | A wish list says |
|---|---|
| "We serve these customers, not those." | "We serve everyone." |
| "We win on this, and we accept we are weaker on that." | "We are the best at everything." |
| "We will do these three things and stop those." | "We will do all of this." |
Wish to strategy (illustrative)
Wish: "We want to be a leading provider of high quality home improvements and grow sales by 25 per cent."
Better: "We win kitchen and bathroom jobs worth £8,000 to £20,000 from homeowners aged 35 to 65 in the Fylde who dread the mess and uncertainty of a big project. We do it by offering design, one project manager and a fixed fitting date, and we say no to price shopping and small repair work. Growth of 25 per cent means about 30 more jobs a year, which needs about 250 qualified leads at a 12 per cent lead to sale rate."
Check: 30 / 0.12 = 250. The better version names the customer, the challenge, the approach and the numbers.
How to fix it
- Write the real challenge in two sentences.
- Choose who you serve and who you do not.
- List what you will stop doing.
Start with the kernel of a good strategy.
Common questions
How can I tell if my strategy is just a wish list?
If it rules nothing out, applies to everyone, or could be copied word for word by a competitor, it is probably a wish list.
Is a long list of priorities bad?
Usually, yes. If everything is a priority, nothing is. A strategy needs a few connected choices.
What is a trade off?
A choice to do one thing and not another, such as serving one type of customer and turning others away.