Five signs your marketing strategy is really a wish list

If nothing is ruled out, you probably do not have a strategy yet.

The short answer. Five signs of bad strategy: fluff in place of meaning, failure to face the challenge, goals mistaken for strategy, a long list of priorities that do not fit together, and no trade offs. A real strategy makes some customers, channels and offers off limits.

From the Marketing Strategy course by Edward Eaton. See what is inside.

The five signs

  • Fluff. Grand words with no meaning, such as "world class customer centric solutions".
  • Failure to face the challenge. There is no diagnosis, so no way to tell whether the actions fit.
  • Goals mistaken for strategy. "Increase sales by 30 per cent" with no explanation of how.
  • Bad objectives. A long list of priorities that do not fit together or tackle the real obstacle.
  • No trade offs. Nothing is ruled out.

Strategy against a wish list

A strategy saysA wish list says
"We serve these customers, not those.""We serve everyone."
"We win on this, and we accept we are weaker on that.""We are the best at everything."
"We will do these three things and stop those.""We will do all of this."

Wish to strategy (illustrative)

Wish: "We want to be a leading provider of high quality home improvements and grow sales by 25 per cent."

Better: "We win kitchen and bathroom jobs worth £8,000 to £20,000 from homeowners aged 35 to 65 in the Fylde who dread the mess and uncertainty of a big project. We do it by offering design, one project manager and a fixed fitting date, and we say no to price shopping and small repair work. Growth of 25 per cent means about 30 more jobs a year, which needs about 250 qualified leads at a 12 per cent lead to sale rate."

Check: 30 / 0.12 = 250. The better version names the customer, the challenge, the approach and the numbers.

How to fix it

  1. Write the real challenge in two sentences.
  2. Choose who you serve and who you do not.
  3. List what you will stop doing.

Start with the kernel of a good strategy.

Common questions

How can I tell if my strategy is just a wish list?

If it rules nothing out, applies to everyone, or could be copied word for word by a competitor, it is probably a wish list.

Is a long list of priorities bad?

Usually, yes. If everything is a priority, nothing is. A strategy needs a few connected choices.

What is a trade off?

A choice to do one thing and not another, such as serving one type of customer and turning others away.

Keep reading

From the course

Marketing Strategy

Marketing Strategy is a 117 page course with an Excel toolkit. It takes you from diagnosis to a written strategy, a budget and a 90 day plan, with worked examples and templates.

Edward EatonEdward EatonMarketing and ads specialist

Want help putting this into practice?

Send a few details about your business and what you want to achieve. You will get an honest view of what to do first.

Or email edward@edwardeatonmarketing.com or call 07817 574416. More about Edward