The kernel of a good strategy, explained for a small business

A good strategy is shorter and plainer than most people expect. It has three parts.

The short answer. Richard Rumelt argues that a good strategy has a kernel of three parts: a diagnosis of the real challenge, a guiding policy for dealing with it, and coherent actions that fit together. It simplifies a messy situation, rules some things out, and replaces a long list of initiatives with a few connected steps.

From the Marketing Strategy course by Edward Eaton. See what is inside.

The three parts

In his book Good Strategy Bad Strategy, Richard Rumelt describes a kernel of three parts. In plain words:

  1. Diagnosis. A clear, honest explanation of what is going on and what the real challenge is. It names the critical issue.
  2. Guiding policy. An overall approach for dealing with that challenge. It rules some things in and many things out.
  3. Coherent actions. Steps that fit together and support the guiding policy, rather than a list of unrelated initiatives.

A worked example (illustrative)

A private physiotherapy clinic with gaps in its diary:

PartStatement
DiagnosisThe clinic has capacity but its diary has gaps midweek. Most new patients come from Google search for pain, where it competes on price with larger chains. Its reviews are strong but unused. The real challenge is that it looks the same as every other physio in search results.
Guiding policyBecome the first choice for active adults who want to keep exercising, by specialising in sports and rehab, and win through speed of access and trust, not price.
Coherent actionsCreate sports and rehab pages and ads. Offer midweek assessment slots. Build partnerships with three local clubs. Collect and show reviews. Stop discount promotions. Track bookings by source monthly.

Why it works

Notice that every action follows from the policy, and the policy follows from the diagnosis. Stopping discounts is not a separate decision. It follows from choosing to win on speed and trust.

Common mistakes

  • Skipping the diagnosis and jumping to ideas.
  • A diagnosis that blames the market and avoids the real problem.
  • A guiding policy so broad that it rules nothing out.
  • Actions that do not connect to each other.

Next, read unit economics for a service business to ground your diagnosis in numbers.

Common questions

Who is Richard Rumelt?

He is a strategy professor and the author of Good Strategy Bad Strategy, which sets out the kernel of diagnosis, guiding policy and coherent action.

How long should a strategy be?

One page is enough to start. If you cannot state the diagnosis, policy and actions briefly, the thinking is probably not clear yet.

Can I use this for marketing only?

Yes. It works for a whole business or for one area such as marketing. The structure is the same.

Keep reading

From the course

Marketing Strategy

Marketing Strategy is a 117 page course with an Excel toolkit. It takes you from diagnosis to a written strategy, a budget and a 90 day plan, with worked examples and templates.

Edward EatonEdward EatonMarketing and ads specialist

Want help putting this into practice?

Send a few details about your business and what you want to achieve. You will get an honest view of what to do first.

Or email edward@edwardeatonmarketing.com or call 07817 574416. More about Edward