How to position a small business: April Dunford's five components
If customers cannot say what you are, who you are for and why to pick you in a few seconds, they move on.
The short answer. Positioning is how you are understood relative to the alternatives. April Dunford's process has five components, worked in order: competitive alternatives, unique attributes, value, best fit customers and market category. Most people start with the slogan and force the facts to fit, which is the common mistake.
From the Marketing Strategy course by Edward Eaton. See what is inside.
What positioning is
Positioning answers a question customers ask silently: what is this, who is it for and why should I pick it over the other options? Al Ries and Jack Trout popularised the idea in the 1970s. In a crowded world, people simplify, so you want to become the obvious answer to one clear question.
Dunford's five components
| # | Component | Question |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Competitive alternatives | What would customers do if we did not exist? |
| 2 | Unique attributes | What do we have that the alternatives do not? |
| 3 | Value | What do those attributes let customers achieve? |
| 4 | Best fit customers | Who cares most about that value? |
| 5 | Market category | What frame makes the value obvious? |
Work in this order. Do not start with the category or the slogan.
A worked example (illustrative): a physiotherapy clinic
| Component | Answer |
|---|---|
| Competitive alternatives | NHS waiting list; big chain clinics; the cheapest local physio; resting and hoping; a personal trainer's advice |
| Unique attributes | Physios who are also runners and cyclists; gym on site for rehab; appointments within 48 hours; a return to sport plan on day one |
| Value | Back to training sooner, with a plan and not just treatment; fewer repeat injuries |
| Best fit customers | Active adults 25 to 55 who train three or more times a week and are frustrated by waiting |
| Market category | "Sports injury and return to sport clinic" and not "physiotherapy clinic" |
"Physiotherapy clinic" invites price comparison with every other physio. "Return to sport clinic" signals a specialist and sets different expectations of what good looks like.
Choosing a category
You can fit an existing category, pick a specialist subcategory, or create a new one. For most small service businesses the subcategory is the sweet spot, such as "bathroom refit specialists for older homes" or "marketing for private clinics". A brand new category needs a lot of explaining.
Test it with real people
Ask three people outside your business to read your page for five seconds, then say what you do and who it is for. If they cannot, simplify. Next, look at value based pricing.
Common questions
What is the difference between positioning and branding?
Positioning is how you are understood compared with the alternatives. Branding is the wider set of memories, feelings and signals people link to you. Positioning comes first.
Should I start with a slogan?
No. Start with the alternatives, your real differences and the customers who care most. The wording comes last.
Do I need a niche?
Not always, but a clear subcategory usually makes you easier to choose and harder to compare on price alone.